Charles Ames Fischer

Teacher Author Consultant Mentor

Discussion and Dialogue

I have been asked about the differences between dialogue and discussion so many times recently that I have decided to add a page here in order to clarify. Understand that these are generalizations that have more or less relevance depending on the individual styles of the group leaders, the nature of the material, the students themselves, etc.

One of the biggest differences is in the power dynamic between the teacher or leader and the students. Discussions are generally teacher-led to the point where even the questions themselves constitute a clear agenda. Participants feel that there is a specific purpose and direction for the discussions and that they are passively along for the ride. Dialogues are student-led and controlled mainly by the participants who create their own emergent group agenda. Participants feel that they are an active part of a shared experience.

Discussion

Discussions are often characterized by brief, individual  answers to exploratory questions and are typically for broadening a topic by collecting multiple opinions. They tend to converge toward a “right” answer or conclusion that is often moderated by the teacher or leader. In discussions, participants tend to throw out individual ideas in the hope that they are relevant and useful and the teacher or leader must often synthesize the comments into a meaningful narrative. In discussions, the teacher is often the one working the hardest.

If you draw a picture of a discussion, where lines represent sections of conversation, then most would run from the teacher out to a single student and back to the teacher, forming V-shapes.

Dialogue

Dialogue, or shared inquiry, is characterized by collaborative answers to provocative questions, and is based in cooperative efforts toward a greater shared understanding. Participants work together to strengthen all positions for mutual benefit. Dialogues tend to diverge toward more questions and expand or deepen conversations. In dialogues, participants must actively listen in order to build upon previous ideas and synthesize for themselves what is important. In dialogues, the students are the ones working the most. There is a wonderful video presentation by Professor Neil Mercer on dialogue, or shared thinking, here

If you draw a picture of a dialogue, where lines represent sections of conversation, then most of the lines would run between students, forming interconnected web shapes.

Discussion

  • Teacher-led
  • Students more passive 
  • Teacher as gatekeeper
  • Tends to be convergent
  • More Broadening
  • Individual-building
  • More personal
  • More self-serving
  • Listen to improve self 
  • Strengthen own position
  • Conclusion-oriented
  • Focus on a few "good" viewpoints
  • Speak to agree or disagree
  • Individual knowledge
  • A few parts added together

 Dialogue

  • Student-led
  • Students more active 
  • Teacher as coach or facilitator 
  • Tends to be divergent
  • More Deepening
  • Team-building
  • More collaborative
  • More altruistic
  • Listen to support others
  • Strengthen all positions
  • Process-oriented
  • Embrace many viewpoints
  • Speak to advance and improve ideas
  • Collective knowledge
  • "The whole is greater than the sum of its parts."

Many thanks to www.greece.k12.ny.us for a great summary of some of the differences.

Quote of the Day

Quote of the Day

Question of the Week

What is your favorite book of all time?

Mystery Box

The word facetious has all five vowels (in order too) and facetiously even includes the letter 'y'. What other words contain all five vowels?

Testimonials

  • "In writing about Charles Fischer, I risk sounding hyperbolic, for I can use nothing but superlatives to describe this special man. He is one of the most enthusiastic, dedicated,..."
    Louise Stilphen
    Headmaster, Sparhawk School lstilphen@sparhawkschool.com

Upcoming Events

No upcoming events

Super Share

Share on Facebook

Subscribe